The future of LOTR TCG

[Smeagollum]

Use the search function on the boards to look up the thought of a PC. June 2008.

Smeagollum, no, I don't. At this point, the only games I play are Rings and Vs. System.
-wtk

That's a pitty, because they've got a pc. And it works. They also have virtual sets. Also fun.

[CategoryOneGames.com]

Don't you wish that the Marvel VS game that was put out for Nintendo DS had a updated version or a DC version.  I love that game on the DS but want MORE to it.  Especially a DC version where I liked the sets much more. 

[ket_the_jet]

C1G...do you want to play via Wi-Fi some time?
-wtk

[Kenddrick]

Do stick to the topic. This section is for the discussion of the lotr tcg pc. Any questions can be asked in pm.

[CategoryOneGames.com]

Got an email back from Cindy and basically said that she and Warren will discuss it but are very busy right now with a new website.  She said that many people have asked this same question before and so they are hesitant.

I'll be sending a followup email letting her know some more background about what we have going on but I think it will work out. 

[Smeagollum]

Maybe an electronic petition would help, but then again I ask myself if there will be enough response to it to be effective.....

[chompers]

I wonder is another reason they are hesitant is the possibility of launching essentially a 2nd Edition of the game when and if The Hobbit ever gets out there? Maybe they want to keep their own fingers in this basket? Just guessing .....

[CategoryOneGames.com]

I got an email from Warren today talking about how this is something they are not ready to do at this time and will look at it again in 2011.  They want to work with the SW and ST groups before getting an official LOTR group together.

He mentioned that a lot of people have asked about this and so they will look at it closer in 2011.

I'll send a followup email saying thank you for their time and so forth and that I will stay in contact with them about the group.

Now we need to discuss on where that leaves us.


I think that having the new site is fine and being a fan site dedicated to the LOTR game and helping to organize and sponsor events is where we need to stand.  We can make rulings and so forth but we cannot do anything with V cards (I didn't want to go this route anyways at the moment) and we can't call ourselves a committee, just a fan site.

Thoughts. . . . .

[Kenddrick]

I got an email from Warren today talking about how this is something they are not ready to do at this time and will look at it again in 2011.  They want to work with the SW and ST groups before getting an official LOTR group together.

He mentioned that a lot of people have asked about this and so they will look at it closer in 2011.

I'll send a followup email saying thank you for their time and so forth and that I will stay in contact with them about the group.

Now we need to discuss on where that leaves us.


I think that having the new site is fine and being a fan site dedicated to the LOTR game and helping to organize and sponsor events is where we need to stand.  We can make rulings and so forth but we cannot do anything with V cards (I didn't want to go this route anyways at the moment) and we can't call ourselves a committee, just a fan site.

Thoughts. . . . .

Agreed. If Big D were to give us permission at this time, we would not be ready. So at least we got till 2011 to set up our foundation nicely. Nice job with the emails!

For the website I think it's best if it stays as a fan site for the time being(to avoid legal issues, and to allow us to set up the PC's foundation). It should be the place to go if you are new to LOTR TCG, or just want to download some starter pdfs to print and play, or to read new articles/decklists!

Then when Decipher gives us permission, hopefully our PC foundation will be strong and the rest will be history.

LONG LIVE LOTR TCG!

[chompers]

I guess that Decipher grant permission to the SW and ST groups for set periods of time. Once that expires perhaps they need to renegotiate terms. Maybe each groups tenure (?) of the product is due to expire in 2010 and needs to be renegotiated.

Hopefully (?) Decipher might be starting to get back on their feet and perhaps have some other business ventures that are keeping them busy as well. Would be nice to see another great product released by Decipher.

The website could serve several purposes including:
* Assisting in organised play (promoting tournaments)
* Providing east access to resources (rulebooks, banned/errata lists, legal printable starters, gccg, zorbecs, etc)
* Networking and linking players (like a player locater)
* Beginners articles
etc

These things may all be on TLHH, but finding them can take a long time. I've been in this stie for a fair while now, and when i explore occasionally i still find a few hidden gems!

One more thing .... The website NEEDS more bandwidth!

[CategoryOneGames.com]

It is different than having to renegotiate and so forth.  I can give you lots of details on both but it deals more with the official structure of both and the legal setup of them.  Nothing to do with having to renegotiate or anything along those lines.  The PC's themselves are fine.'

But yes I do think it gives us time to setup a more secure basis to what we are looking at to move forward once we get an approval for a PC. 

[Orangejedi]

C1G:  This is the same song and dance I got back in 2007.  Don't believe for a second they give a rat's <tail> about the community or anything.  We had a group of highly organized and highly trained people ready to go.  (You would not believe the amount of help and latitude Girard gave us when he was there, esp when Bojo was still there to help).  I had 15 people ready to step up and give their time and effort into the pc, including those who were former judges, former playtesters, former dagents, the works.  Unfortunately the legalities of it all mean you need D's permission to create cards/use the template/use the name.  The only things you can do without them are edit x-lists and have unofficial events (like worlds this year). 

Basically, for those of you pissed off that a PC was never formed before, this is why.  It wasn't for lack of effort, caring, or ability.  It was the bottom line.  Warren had tons of SW stuff and a new game out that encouraged him to keep a relationship with the players.  Now he's got squat and is holding anyone who wants to play in an organized manner by the cajones. 

Warren will get back to you in 2011.  He'll say "we've got a new game, and we're going to do that."  And then get back to them in 2012.  Don't think for a second that they care about the players until they have a new game to peddle. 

Sorry for being so mean spirited, but if you had tried to work with Brad and Kendrick in 2007, you would've felt the same way. 

Seth

[Kenddrick]

!

[CategoryOneGames.com]

OrangeJedi that is what I was told from other people that were part of that group as well.  I'm not really discouraged as what I want to see with the game is what you said we can work on at this point.  The game doesn't have a big enough group to really support V cards at the moment nor people that could make them and playtest them to the level probably needed.

I think we can still run with a 'fan' site that has card lists, message boards and helps organize events.  I think that will help start to rebuild some.

Girard is getting back into SW though from the looks of it and should be at Worlds this year.  That should be cool and I'll try to talk to him some about it then too. 

[Kenddrick]

I've been a bit tied up these 2-3 months but I'll be back to continue on the site and the PC!